WTA Player of the Year: Barty, Osaka or Andreescu?

Published by Matt Trollope

(L-R) Australian Open champion Naomi Osaka, French Open winner Ash Barty and US Open champion Bianca Andreescu are vying for WTA Player of the Year honours. (Getty Images)
All Grand Slam champions in 2019, Ash Barty, Naomi Osaka and Bianca Andreescu have enjoyed stellar seasons. But which of them has been the best?

This season has been a thrilling one for the women’s tour, with young guns Ash Barty and Bianca Andreescu emerging in 2019 to join another youthful superstar, Naomi Osaka, among the highest rungs of the WTA rankings. All three are firmly in the running for WTA Player of the Year honours.

Osaka, 22, last year announced her arrival in a big way with victory at the US Open. And she backed that up in January with her second straight major title at the Australian Open — a triumph that came the No.1 ranking.

Osaka held onto top spot until June, when Barty’s brilliant victory at Roland Garros and subsequent title in Birmingham saw her take ownership of the No.1 ranking.

RANKINGS WATCH: Is Barty on track for year-end No.1?

The came September, and 19-year-old Andreescu’s stunning run to the US Open title — a triumph seeing her join Barty and Osaka in the top five.

As well as the fact Barty, Osaka and Andreescu are all now reigning Grand Slam champions, they have all won Premier Mandatory titles in 2019 and are now all ranked inside the top four. Each player has won three singles titles this season.

There is one more big tournament to come — the WTA Finals in Shenzhen, for which this trio have qualified — yet their body of work in 2019 is practically complete.

So which one of them do you think is the Player of the Year? We present the stats from 2019 so you can decide.

Match wins

If we restrict this category to tour-level victories in 2019, Barty is well ahead of her rivals. But considering Andreescu’s additional victories in qualifying draws and at non tour-level events, the Canadian closes the gap. And we don’t think these can be discounted, given those wins contributed both to her ranking points tally and made it possible for her to feature in WTA main draws.

BARTY OSAKA ANDREESCU
Win-loss record 52-11 39-13 48-6
Record vs top 10 8-5 5-1 8-1
Record vs top 5 2-2 1-0 4-1
Fed Cup record* 6-0 2-0
Longest win streak 15 10^ 17

*includes both singles and doubles
^active streak

 

Rankings

BARTY OSAKA ANDREESCU
Movement in 2019 #15 to #1 (+14) #5 to #3 (+2) #152 to #4 (+148)
Weeks at No.1 13* 21

*currently ranked No.1

 

Grand Slam record

AO RG W US Win-loss
BARTY QF W R4 R4 17-3
OSAKA W R3 R1 R4 12-3
ANDREESCU R2* R2 W ^9-1

*as a qualifier
^record improves to 12-1 when counting qualifying victories at AO 

 

Notable victories at Slams

Includes seeded players (marked by #ranking), Grand Slam champions and former world No.1s

BARTY #30 Sharapova (AO); #14 Keys (RG); #29 Sakkari (US)
OSAKA #6 Kvitova, #7 Svitolina, #8 Pliskova, #12 Sevastova, #27 Hsieh (AO); Azarenka (RG)
ANDREESCU #8 S.Williams, #13 Bencic, #19 Wozniacki, #26 Mertens (all US)

 

Titles/finals

Here, Barty earns points for the fact her titles came on three different surfaces — clay at Roland Garros, hard in Miami, and grass in Birmingham. Both Osaka and Andreescu notched all their titles/finals on hard courts only.

Helping break the deadlock could be next week’s WTA Finals in Shenzhen, which could also go a long way to determining who the official Player of the Year will be.

Titles Finals
BARTY (3) Roland Garros, Miami, Birmingham (2) Beijing, Sydney
OSAKA (3) Australian Open, Beijing, Osaka
ANDREESCU (3) US Open, Indian Wells, Toronto (1) Auckland

 

Prize money ($US)

BARTY $6,887,587
OSAKA $5,863,282
ANDREESCU $6,239,150

 

Losses to players outside top 50

For Barty, two of these losses come with somewhat of an asterisk; Kuznetsova is a two-time major champion and former world No.2 while Riske has since gone on to crack the top 20.

BARTY #153 Kuznetsova (Cincinnati), #63 Mladenovic (Rome), #55 Riske (Wimbledon)
OSAKA #67 Mladenovic (Dubai)
ANDREESCU
Share this: 
  • Most popular articles

29 April 2016

How to beat a better player

Victory was never out of the question when Bernard Tomic faced 17-time Grand Slam champion... More

15 September 2016

The 10 most influential players in the history of tennis

The greatest champions, goes the old adage, are those who leave their sport better than th... More

11 May 2017

Woodbridge: Why Rafa is so good on clay

When we look at Rafa Nadal on clay, there are a few key points that make him better than e... More

28 June 2017

Rain delays and getting nude: the social round-up

Rain meant there hasn't been much tennis played in the past 24 hours - but thankfully that... More